2. The straw bridge with a penny cup
Needs straws, tape, a cup, pennies. Groups of four. 40 minutes. Mess: low.
Teams tape straws into a 12-inch span, hang a cup in the middle, and load pennies into it until the bridge fails. The penny count is a real result, and 5th graders want to beat it. As usually run, though, it’s a strength contest with one number on the board, or a display: one district we visited had the bridges in glass cases down the hallway, built from the instruction “build a bridge,” beautiful, and never tested. Nobody can say who built what, or where any bridge broke.
The fix
- Give each team four roles: Builder, Materials Lead, Loader, and Recorder.
- Keep a load log: before each add, the team predicts, and the Recorder writes the penny count.
- Debrief on where every bridge broke, one bridge at a time.
The load log is on the sheet’s back; the fix above is the whole of it.




